Annemann

If Dunninger made mind reading famous and Canasta made it sophisticated, it was Theodore Annemann who gave it its foundations. He was not the greatest showman of the mentalists, nor the most celebrated in his lifetime, but he was the most important. In a career cut tragically short he invented, refined and, above all, wrote down the techniques and the thinking that turned mentalism from a fairground novelty into a serious performing art. Almost every mind reader working today, whether they know his name or not, is standing on ground that Annemann cleared.

From Theodore Squires to Annemann

He was born Theodore John Squires on 22 February 1907 in Waverly, a small town in upstate New York. His father left when the boy was very young, and his mother remarried a man named Stanley Anneman, whose surname Theodore took as his own. The distinctive double "n" came later, his own refinement, added around 1930. A schoolboy friend showed him the old Ball and Vase trick, and the spark caught at once; he became, by his own family's account, obsessed with magic.

His path into the profession was unglamorous. He worked for a time as a railway clerk, then drifted into show business as a tenor singer and a magician's assistant. By his late teens he was already contributing original effects to the leading magic journals of the day, The Sphinx and The Linking Ring, building a reputation not for finger-flinging dexterity but for cleverness, for the ability to turn a simple principle into something that felt like a genuine miracle.

Finding the Mind

Annemann began, as so many did, in the costume of the old-fashioned mystic, performing as a mind reader in turban and cape. The established magician Al Baker, initially a rival and later a close friend, advised him to throw all that away and present himself as a modern man in a modern suit. It was sound advice and Annemann took it. The fairground seer became a quietly unsettling figure in evening dress, and the persona suited both his material and his temperament. He came to be billed as "Annemann the Enigma," and through the 1930s he was widely regarded as the finest mentalist of his generation.

The Jinx

In October 1934 Annemann launched the publication that would secure his immortality: The Jinx. It was a modest-looking magazine, marked by its impish black cat emblem, but its contents were extraordinary. Focused chiefly on mentalism, though it welcomed first-rate effects from every branch of magic, it became the most important and most eagerly awaited magician's journal of its day. Each issue carried not only methods but Annemann's own sharp editorial voice, his opinions, his wit and his hard-won wisdom about what actually worked in front of a real audience.

It began as a monthly, but such was its popularity that in 1939 it went weekly. It ran to one hundred and fifty-one issues before publication ceased in 1941, and original copies have long since become treasured collector's items. So enduring is its value that the entire run has been gathered and reprinted in modern bound editions, keeping Annemann's thinking in the hands of new performers more than eighty years on.

The Inventor: Billets, Tears and the Swami

Annemann's genius was for method, and specifically for method so direct that it left no seam for the audience to find. He took principles that were often old and made them practical, reliable and bold. His work on the billet, the small slip of paper on which a spectator writes a secret which the mentalist then divines, was definitive. His handling of the centre tear, the apparently innocent destruction of that paper, remains a cornerstone of the art to this day. He explored the swami gimmick, the tiny device that lets a performer secretly write a prediction at the last possible moment, and turned it into a workhorse of the profession. These are not flashy inventions. They are the quiet machinery on which a thousand miracles still run.

His philosophy of performance was as influential as any single method, and he stated it plainly.

It is a sentence worth committing to memory. Where lesser performers reached for ever more elaborate apparatus, Annemann understood that complexity is the enemy of mystery, and that the cleanest method, delivered with total conviction, is always the most deceptive.

The Writer

Annemann was prolific on the page. He produced a steady stream of books and manuscripts across his short career, among them 202 Methods of Forcing (1933), SH-H-H! It's a Secret (1934) and En Rapport (1937). His true monument, however, was assembled after his death. In 1944 the editor John J. Crimmins gathered the best of his work into Practical Mental Effects, also published as Annemann's Practical Mental Magic. It became, and remains, one of the most important books ever written on the subject, a comprehensive manual that has trained generation after generation of mentalists and has never been out of print. Its influence reaches far beyond his own language; his material has been translated and studied around the world.

The Bullet Catch

For all his emphasis on simplicity, Annemann was also celebrated for one of the most dangerous feats in all of magic: the bullet catch, in which a marked bullet, apparently fired from a real gun, is caught by the performer. He developed his own version, performed in the open air, and presented it with grim theatricality, collapsing as if struck before producing the bullet. It made his name with the public, yet by many accounts he came to dread it, for the psychological toll of repeatedly facing a loaded weapon was immense. It is a poignant irony that the man who preached calm, simple directness should be bound to so perilous and nerve-shredding a signature piece.

A Life Cut Short

Behind the assured stage figure was a troubled man. Annemann struggled for years with alcohol, with anxiety and with financial hardship, and the strain told. On 12 January 1942, amid these difficulties and shortly before he was due to present his bullet catch indoors for the first time, he took his own life. He was just thirty-four. He left a wife and a young daughter, and a profession stunned by the loss of a man at the very height of his powers. The Jinx had already ceased; with his death an extraordinary creative engine fell silent.

Legacy

Annemann's influence is, quite simply, incalculable. Every mentalist working today is using techniques that he either invented, refined or first set down clearly on paper. His insistence that mentalism deserved rigorous, intellectual treatment lifted the art from sideshow curiosity to serious discipline, and his writing remains a masterclass in clarity, creativity and practical sense. The performers who followed, Dunninger on the airwaves, Canasta on television, Corinda in the great instructional tradition, and the modern psychological entertainers after them, all built upon foundations he laid. He died young and largely unrewarded, but he left the richest inheritance of any figure in the history of mind reading.

The original version of this article appeared in The Magic Circular, the official journal of The Magic Circle.

Original Magic Circular Article

Read the Theodore Annemann feature as originally published in The Magic Circular, November 2014.

Read the PDF