For someone who was a media icon throughout her life, of film-start stature, and whoamazed Albert Einstein and predicted the future for President Franklin Roosevelt and countless US governors, senators and mayors, it is surprising that little is remembered of this fantastic mind reader and a celebrity of huge standing in her day. Alongside Joseph Dunninger, she was America’s best-known psychic performer of the 1920s and 1930s and was one of the most talked about stars of that era. An incredible story of a beautiful young lady who became a celebrity, Gene Dennis went from small town-Kansas teenage prodigy to an American favourite, with a long career of live appearances, radio shows, and international headlines. Newspapers loved her movie-star glamour and published one long-lashed beauty shot after another. She performed on two continents and became England’s first radio mind reader before marrying a multimillionaire and retiring from the stage.
Eugenie Dennis was born in Topeka, Kansas in 1904 She later became known as Eugene and finally as simply Gene Dennis. Gene was a well-spoken child raised in a modest home by her parents Nannie and Frank (a pattern maker for a locomotive upholstery company). The family later moved to nearby Atchison
Nannie recounted that her own mother was psychic and would see pictures and could find lost objects and her beliefs certainly influenced young Gene who, apparently, could talk at ten months and at two years old started speaking of seeing visions. When Gene was eight, a visit from a local tailor named Ike Gilberg changed her life. Gilberg, fascinated with Jewish metaphysics, was a local philanthropist who helped Dennis’ family pay their bills when her father was ill and unable to work around 1914. One day, Gilberg stopped by the Dennis’ home and was struck by the young Eugenie’s poise and insight. He told Eugenie’s mother that the girl was a psychic and should develop her gifts.
The sudden fame and responsibility were intense and tough for the teenager to handle. The sheer volume of letters and requests being received overwhelmed Gene at the time; she would often become tearful with a desire to respond to everyone’s requests. Her fame spread quickly and a 1921 article in the Minneapolis Star. With the headline “Mysterious Exploits of a 16 year old Mind-Reader” recounted how Gene had helped find lost jewellery, money and even oil for a drilling company (as Uri Geller attempted some years later).
What is clear is that Abbott and his wife became good friends with Gene, who they did not consider with the disdain of some mediums who they felt simply exploited their followers and clients. Gene’s sittings appeared much more supportive of her clients as opposed to the exploitative nature of other mediums. Also, Gene did not claim to consult the spirits or go into a trance to get her readings. Abbott wrote a booklet on Gene entitled The Wonder Woman but never published it (a copy is in the excellent House of Mystery book referenced below). Some years later Gene asked Abbott if he could help her publish a booklet on psychic matters that she could sell at her shows – splitting the money 50:50 Abbott agreed to do this.
Along with other successful performers Gene quickly realized how eager newspapers were to publish her predictions, particularly those relating to crimes, and she exploited this to the max. On one occasion whilst giving readings at Abbot’s house she had a premonition of a murder only to later discover that a policeman had in fact been killed that night, this premonition was widely reported in the press adding to her ‘credibility’. She also benefited from the fact that the papers rarely published follow ups about whether or not her predictions came true, although she did take more prudence after unsuccessfully predicting a Californian earthquake would flatten Los Angeles due to the sins of Hollywood!
Her manager used every opportunity to increase her marketability, including going to the press and announcing a three year $52,000-a-year motion picture deal with his newly set up production company (although no film ever materialised). Late in 1922 Gene was reported to have met with author and psychic believer Sir Arthur Conan Doyle who was to later announce “Gene is one of the Seven Wonders of the World” which along with added publicity from psychic investigator Abbot who said she was “A Perfect Psychic Phenomenon”, her ascendancy couldn’t be better …although Houdini, in his role as psychic exposed gave an explanation on her ‘murder revelation’ on his popular radio article ‘Ghosts that talk – by Radio’… Explaining an elaborate use of transmitting antennae, sensitive headphones concealed in flowers on her shoulders, and a willing reporter sending her messages! Whether this was the case Gene certainly had the funds and contacts to make it happen. Houdini claimed she had reporters at hospitals, police stations and newspaper offices to specifically transmit live any major incident that would make the press! Abbott didn’t take kindly to these claims and published an article refuting Houdini’s claims
Her ability to offer information that could never be known unless there was something psychic going on continued to amaze, astound and bring in huge press and media attention. She once surprised a a reported by revealing the contents of his will, described his friends and relatives, including giving information on their health, she amazed police by disclosing unreleased information on unsolved crimes, she correctly predicted the winner or a journalism scholarship prize and often correctly predicted the winners on local sports matches (often predicting the local team’s win to endear herself to the locals).
Her positive publicity was briefly halted when she was served with a summons fand found guilty of fortune telling, which was illegal in many states. This followed a complaint from a disgruntled client who was given an inaccurate reading when Gene told her that her lost son was in another city when in fact he was still in his hometown. A $25 fine and some poor press ensued which actually did little to curb her continual growth in popularity. The court leniency was helped incidentally, at the hearing by support from the police who had stated that Gene had helped them solve a number of cases in the past.
Her success continued even with some criticism from some press. The New York Times printed an intelligent piece questioning her credibility as a ‘solver of mysteries’ (as she was also known), with claims of supernatural or supernormal powers. They suggested at best she made educated guesses, and as for her work with the police they claimed it was a complete waste of time. Despite all of this her career blossomed and with the ever-growing movie industry was often asked to open premiers, often gaining as much publicity as the movie stars themselves. Her popularity within the industry (she often gave readings to directors and actors in Hollywood), she moved to the prestigious Grauman Egyptian Theatre. She continued to tour the larger theatres, taking out two –page press adverts and getting formal thanks from the mayor in each city for predicting their re-election and highlighting her lost property skills as in the case she claimed to finding stolen diamonds from a Market Street Jeweler.
`For the next years Gene took some breaks from performing, investing in the stock market. She returned to the stage in 1929 following the Crash and presumably after losing some money, although she did claim to have withdrawn her funds when she foresaw the collapse coming! In 1930 Gene bgan a prestigious two year contract with Loew’s, and was now represented by the powerful William Morris Agency.
The great appeal of Gene Dennis was her girl-next door appearance, which set her apart from the usual solemn turbaned soothsayers; she also strenuously objected to being called ‘mystic’ or a ‘mind reader’, as too did she deny anything supernatural in her strange powers. She would invite sceptical journalists to meet her and astound them with revelations of personal details that were quite remarkable. She never forgot David Abbotts support in her early career and in 1931 gave an interview complimenting his contribution to her career.
The positive press kept coming. “Amazing!” Albert Einstein proclaimed the front page of the Chicago Herald Examiner on 13th January 1932, following spending sevel hours with Gene – “She told me things no one possibly could know, things on which I have been working, and she demonstrated that she has a power to do things U cannot explain. I must tell some of my associates about this It was miraculous indeed. A year later in 1931 the Warner Circus announced it had signed Gene for a forty-week tour at a salary of $2000 a week. “This is reported the highest figure ever paid to a mind reader”. She continued to receive huge publicity and after performing in Washington theatres sge performed for President Franklin Roosevelt during a White House dinner.
The 1930s brought Gene more publicity including a glamorous bathing suit shot on a 1931 cover of the New York Graphic captioned “Gene Dennis: Mystic Marvel, Athletic Girl”
Gene’s fame extended to Europe and in 1934 she travelled to London for Theatre bookings and radio interviews, where she is said to have been the first ‘psychic / mind reader’ to appear on British radio; she was loved by her British audiences and even successfully predicted the winner of the Derby horse race. She continued to tour in the US and returning to the UK.
In Paris in 1935 the now 31 year old Gene secretly married John G. Von Herbert, 55, the wealthy Seattle owner of several theatres and the Seattle Farmer’s Market. The couple had five children (strangely with names all based on mum – Denny, Jay, Jensen, Jeannie and Virginia). Whilst Gene restricted her stage work, she still kept her hand in psychic matters, writing an advice column in the Seattle Star and editing her own monthly self-help magazine, Amity, She also still made occasional predictions. In 1947 Von Herberg died. Three months later, on 8th March 1948, Gene herself passed away at the young age of 44, leaving five young children. Whilst doctors diagnosed Cerebral edema, or an excess of water on the brain as the cause, her friends said she passed away grief-stricken from her husbands death. Struggles with alcohol may have contributed to her early demise.
House of Mystery. The Magic Science of David P. Abbott edited by Teller and Todd Karr. The Miracle Factory. pgs 324 – 348
Much of this article has been extracted and edited from the excellent book and the chapter ‘Abbott and the Schoolgirl Psychic’